Censorship Coordination Deepens – WSJ

- Advertisement -



Photo:

dado ruvic/Reuters

The Biden Administration sure isn’t taking

Donald Trump’s

Big Tech lawsuits seriously. A week after the former President’s lawyers argued in court filings that his removal by social-media firms amounted to “state action,” the Administration broadcast that it is coordinating with the firms to remove content.

“We’re flagging problematic posts for

Facebook,

” said White House Press Secretary

Jen Psaki

on Thursday, referring to coronavirus misinformation. Meanwhile, the Surgeon General, an officer in the department of Health and Human Services, released a report with a page of suggestions on “what technology platforms can do” to crack down on certain information. The Verge reported that officials at

Twitter

“met with the surgeon general’s office on Monday to discuss its misinformation policies.”

It’s been clear for some time that the tech giants look to government to determine what coronavirus-related speech to allow. YouTube’s misinformation policy bans content that contradicts the evolving guidance of “health authorities.” Facebook stopped blocking some commentary on the lab-leak theory of the virus’s origins only after President Biden ordered an investigation into the possibility.

Public-private coordination is not in itself sinister. The government can be an important source of information, and most people would agree that it’s not an abuse of Facebook’s authority to suppress, say, fraudulent medical advice that goes viral.

Yet as the acute crisis phase of coronavirus passes, a government arrangement with private firms to control speech about the pandemic looks less salutary. We don’t know how deep the coordination goes, and Mr. Trump’s lawsuit makes a weak case. We also don’t know to what extent the platforms are complying with the White House in what they consider the public interest, or if they also fear retaliation.

A better plaintiff would be an individual who can prove his coronavirus-related speech was “flagged” by the U.S. government for censorship, and that Facebook complied. So much the better if the speech is not only constitutionally protected, but also true, or partly true, in an area where the authorities were wrong.

This logic is not confined to the legal right. The liberal Harvard law professor Noah Feldman wrote this week that “current constitutional doctrine doesn’t clearly lay out how much government coercion of a private actor’s speech decisions it would take to constitute a First Amendment violation.”

Mr. Trump’s claim doesn’t qualify, in Mr. Feldman’s view, but “under at least some circumstances, that threat should be actionable.” Wherever the legal line is drawn, the rise in Big Tech censorship that happens to align with government preferences ought to draw scrutiny. If it can happen on coronavirus, it can happen on other issues. Americans shouldn’t let that become the new normal.

In response to the July 11 uprising in Cuba, President Miguel Diaz-Canel initiated an internet blackout to prevent anti-government protestors use of social media to energize the people. Image: Yamil Lage/AFP via Getty Images

Copyright ©2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Appeared in the July 17, 2021, print edition.

Latest news

U.S. Stock Futures Edge Up Ahead of Jobless Figures, GDP Data

U.S. stock futures edged up ahead of data that are expected to show a decline...

Australian Olympic track team isolating after U.S. athlete tests positive for COVID-19 – National

American double world champion pole vaulter Sam Kendricks and German Chiaraviglio of Argentina have been ruled out of the Olympics after testing positive for...

Credit Suisse Report Pins Archegos Disaster on ‘Fundamental Failure of Management and Controls’

Credit Suisse Group AG said top employees failed to act on numerous warning...

Ever Given, the Ship That Blocked the Suez, Makes It to Port

ROTTERDAM, Netherlands—The Ever Given, the container ship that blocked the Suez Canal for days and...
Related news

U.S. Stock Futures Edge Up Ahead of Jobless Figures, GDP Data

U.S. stock futures edged up ahead of data that are expected to show a decline...

Australian Olympic track team isolating after U.S. athlete tests positive for COVID-19 – National

American double world champion pole vaulter Sam Kendricks and German Chiaraviglio of Argentina have been ruled out of the Olympics after testing positive for...

Credit Suisse Report Pins Archegos Disaster on ‘Fundamental Failure of Management and Controls’

Credit Suisse Group AG said top employees failed to act on numerous warning...

Ever Given, the Ship That Blocked the Suez, Makes It to Port

ROTTERDAM, Netherlands—The Ever Given, the container ship that blocked the Suez Canal for days and...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here