The Meaning of Biden’s Firing Spree

- Advertisement -

President Joe Biden fired Social Security Administration Commissioner Andrew Saul on July 9.



Photo:

J. Scott Applewhite/Associated Press

The Biden Administration may be the most progressive in decades, but it is accelerating a conservative revolution in presidential power over the federal bureaucracy. The latest example is the President’s sacking Friday of Social Security Administration (SSA) commissioner

Andrew Saul,

the

Trump

appointee whose six-year term wouldn’t have expired until 2025.

Democrats in Congress lobbied for Mr. Saul’s firing because he displeased federal employee unions. Mr.

Biden

has been aggressive in purging the federal government of Trump appointees, even those like the SSA commissioner who typically serve under Presidents of both parties. The Administration has also broken norms by axing the National Labor Relations Board general counsel and leaders at the U.S. Commission on Fine Arts and the Administrative Conference of the U.S.

In a legal memo justifying the firing of Mr. Saul, the Biden White House pointed to the Supreme Court’s decisions in Seila Law v. CFPB (2020), which held that the President could fire the head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and Collins v.

Yellen

(2021) which held that he can fire the head of the Federal Housing Finance Agency.

Those decisions were a major blow to the favored progressive model of governance, which sees agencies insulated from accountability as preferable to traditional democratic processes. Mr. Biden’s nominee to lead the CFPB,

Rohit Chopra,

in 2018 proposed a new agency to regulate political lobbying headed by a virtually unremovable director with a term of up to 10 years.

Yet Democrats are now adopting the conservative view that a President ought to be able to exert greater control over executive agencies. This shift comes from partisanship, not principle, but it could have lasting implications.

If Mr. Saul sues to serve out his statutory tenure, and the case makes its way to the Supreme Court, it would present the Justices with a novel question about agency accountability. The Court’s conservative majority could build on its Seila Law precedent.

More significant, it could reconsider two of its mistaken decisions limiting presidential control over bureaucracies—Morrison v.

Olson

(1988) on the independent counsel statute, and Humphrey’s Executor (1935) on independent agencies. A legal complaint by

Roger Severino,

whose three-year term on the council of the Administrative Conference was cut short in February, cites the latter case in demanding his reinstatement. A savvy legal shop representing Mr. Saul could bring those issues to the fore.

Progressives cringed when Mr. Trump or his supporters spoke of a “deep state” and “

Obama

holdovers.” Yet Mr. Biden’s firing spree shows that, especially in a time of heightened polarization, officials appointed by a prior President of either party may differ with an incoming Administration in meaningful ways. The constitutional approach is to let a new President pick his own personnel, so his Administration can be accountable to Congress and in elections.

Even the Biden Administration is now operating as if it endorses the originalist view of a unitary executive. Conservatives may not like the policy results of this in the short term, but the long-term result could be a more accountable government.

Journal Editorial Report: Paul Gigot interviews Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost. Image: Joshua Roberts/Bloomberg News

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Appeared in the July 13, 2021, print edition.

Latest news

Didi Global Considers Going Private to Placate China and Compensate Investors

HONG KONG—Ride-hailing giant Didi Global Inc. is considering going private in order to...

Didi Global Considers Going Private to Placate China and Compensate Investors

HONG KONG—Ride-hailing giant Didi Global Inc. is considering going private in order to...

While you were sleeping: How Canada performed Wednesday, Thursday at Tokyo Olympics – National

Canada won its first rowing medal at the Tokyo Olympics on Thursday, continuing the women athletes’ dominance in these Summer Games. Here’s what else you...

Australia takes gold in first-ever women’s canoe slalom at Tokyo Olympics – National

Australia’s Jessica Fox won gold in the first ever Olympic women’s canoe slalom on Thursday, adding to a kayak slalom bronze earlier this week,...
Related news

Didi Global Considers Going Private to Placate China and Compensate Investors

HONG KONG—Ride-hailing giant Didi Global Inc. is considering going private in order to...

Didi Global Considers Going Private to Placate China and Compensate Investors

HONG KONG—Ride-hailing giant Didi Global Inc. is considering going private in order to...

While you were sleeping: How Canada performed Wednesday, Thursday at Tokyo Olympics – National

Canada won its first rowing medal at the Tokyo Olympics on Thursday, continuing the women athletes’ dominance in these Summer Games. Here’s what else you...

Australia takes gold in first-ever women’s canoe slalom at Tokyo Olympics – National

Australia’s Jessica Fox won gold in the first ever Olympic women’s canoe slalom on Thursday, adding to a kayak slalom bronze earlier this week,...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here